Skip to content

The Art of Civic Protest and Demonstration: Love Your Enemy

Roses of Various Colors

By Vahid Razavi

Over the past few months as I traveled across the globe I have had the chance to talk with college students on campuses. They are rightfully upset. Housing they cannot afford. Jobs they are told will go to AI and robots. A feeling that the people building that future see them as “useless eaters,” a phrase from the darkest chapter of the last century.1 And on their phones, every day, the images of genocide and war crimes. They have every right to be upset, and every right to demonstrate.

They are also living under a new gospel of indifference. The richest man in the world told Joe Rogan in February 2025 that “the fundamental weakness of Western civilization is empathy.” He added that he believes in empathy, but for “civilization as a whole.”2 His own daughter, Vivian Jenna Wilson, cut ties with him and legally dropped his name in 2022.3 His first wife, Justine Wilson, speaks against him on camera in Alex Gibney’s new documentary, Musk. She says that after their daughter came out, he asked her to tell Vivian he would always love her, and cut off Vivian’s health insurance the next day.4 Musk did not take part in the film and calls it a hit piece.5 I don’t say any of this with hatred. As I wrote in my last book, I say it with pity.

This essay is for those students.

Flowers in the Barrel of a Gun

I have protested war since I was a child. My earliest memories are of demonstrations, riding on my father’s shoulders and shouting with the crowd. I cherish those memories. I read the news, watched the evening broadcasts, and listened to the Voice of America, BBC Persian, and Russian and Iranian radio to guess where the next bomb would fall.

During the Iranian revolution, I remember women placing flowers, carnations and tulips, into the barrels of soldiers’ rifles. Those soldiers were armed and ready to shoot pigeons and people alike. The crowds chanted, “Artesh baradar-e mast”: “The army is our brother.”

Here is the part they don’t teach you in school: it worked. Flowers offered day after day against live ammunition wore down the army’s will. Conscripts refused to fire and deserted in growing numbers, and on February 11, 1979, the military’s leaders declared the army neutral.6 That is not sentimentality. That is strategy.

Those “brothers” were most likely a neighbor’s neglected son: a boy who never got the love and attention he needed, or whose family was too poor to educate him and sent him into the army hoping it would give him what home could not.

Love Is a Strategy, Not a Sentiment

To love your enemy matters more to a radical nonviolent movement than any weapon the state brings to the street. Martin Luther King Jr. understood this. In his sermon “Loving Your Enemies,” he separated love into three kinds, eros, philia and agape, and taught that agape means loving the person who does the evil deed while hating the deed itself.7 Loving your oppressor does not mean liking him. It means refusing to mirror his hatred, which takes away the excuse he uses to crush you.

Gandhi called this satyagraha: “truth-force” or “soul-force.”8 In his autobiography he wrote that “Hate the sin and not the sinner” is easy to understand but rarely practiced, “and that is why the poison of hatred spreads in the world.”9 The Buddha said it twenty-five centuries ago: “Hatred is never appeased by hatred in this world. By non-hatred alone is hatred appeased.”10

I do not believe in passive nonresistance. Demonstrators should not sit and wait to be arrested one at a time. They should do what I saw as a child: offer flowers, and embrace the very people sent to arrest and hurt them.

Understand who is standing in front of you. The officer or soldier in uniform may come from a home that denied him love and attention. He may have been abused, and learned to abuse. He carries what he knows best, the cycle of violence from his home and the dehumanization he was taught in the academy or the barracks, now with a badge and a uniform. He is also a victim. Show him pity and kindness. Disarm him, or her, with love.

When you see protesters breaking windows or doing worse, remember that they may be carrying the same wounds as the officers, or they may be paid provocateurs sent to discredit a peaceful demonstration. When they vandalize your streets, your stores and your community, be the first to try to stop them. If you cannot, separate yourself from them, and come back the next day to repair the damage to your beloved community.

What History Teaches

Before my broken back, I took part in many demonstrations, and I learned that tactics matter. Strategy matters. We have to learn from the efforts that worked. And I am not only talking about Iran.

Washington, 1967. At the March on the Pentagon, photographer Bernie Boston captured an eighteen-year-old named George Harris placing carnations into the barrels of rifles held by military police. The photo, “Flower Power,” became a global icon.11 The poet Allen Ginsberg had coined that phrase two years earlier. That afternoon it became an image: a terrifying military line turned into a canvas of peace.

Prague, 1989. When riot police attacked students on November 17, the students held up their open palms and chanted “Máme holé ruce!”: “We have bare hands!” In the days that followed, people placed flowers and candles in front of the police lines and looked individual officers in the eye. Many students were beaten, but no one was killed, and within six weeks the dissident playwright Václav Havel was president. History calls it the Velvet Revolution.12

Moscow, 1991. When hardliners tried to overthrow Mikhail Gorbachev and sent tanks into the streets, ordinary people surrounded them. They climbed onto the tanks and offered the young soldiers food, cigarettes, flowers and conversation. Some tank crews switched sides and turned their guns away from the crowd. Three young men died in the streets, but within three days the coup collapsed.13

Kyiv, 2004. During the Orange Revolution, protesters, often mothers and grandmothers, brought food and flowers to the riot police, and young women tucked carnations into the officers’ shields so the conscripts would see their own sisters and daughters in the crowd. The protests stayed peaceful, and the stolen election was run again.14 Ten years later, the Maidan protests began the same way but ended in gunfire, with more than one hundred protesters killed.15 That is a lesson too. Nonviolence is a discipline, and it has to be held by everyone, above all by those who hold the guns.

In every one of these stories, the tactic was the same. Treat the armed enforcer as a human being, not as the enemy. Disarm him with dignity. Make it psychologically impossible for him to swing the baton or pull the trigger.

Do Not Feed the Machine of Violence

We cannot beat batons, water cannons and chemical sprays with more batons and violence. That is exactly what the system wants. Look at what trends on social media today. First, sexualized content and spying gadgets: in January 2026, Grok, the AI on Elon Musk’s X, spent weeks “undressing” photos of real women and even children until regulators stepped in,16 and camera glasses can now record you without your knowing. Second, AI-generated dancing cats and the other “trends” the algorithm suggests you copy. Third, violence.

The system is designed to discourage critical thinking. It is designed to make violence normal and to make us numb to it. We scroll past images of genocide and don’t think twice about the companies, and the executives, whose technology is part of the machinery. Do not feed the machine of violence.

After all the demonstrations I have seen over the years, I recently watched a video from Serbia: students cleaning up graffiti and trash left by agitators after a protest. It was a beautiful sight.

They Call Us Useless

The tech elite talk about a future run by AI and humanoid robots. I can tell you, as a man with more than twenty pieces of metal in his body, who once had two broken ankles at the same time and has been through more than two hundred physical therapy sessions to walk again: human walking is a controlled fall. Every step forward is a fall we catch. We are not the most efficient design for a robot. We were never meant to be.

Some of the people building these machines are not even sure they want us to stay. In June 2025, New York Times columnist Ross Douthat asked Peter Thiel, the PayPal co-founder and Palantir backer: “You would prefer the human race to endure, right?” Thiel paused. “You’re hesitating,” Douthat said. Thiel: “Well, I don’t know. I would — I would —” Douthat: “This is a long hesitation!” Douthat had to ask a second time: “Should the human race survive?” Only then did Thiel say yes, followed by: “But I also would like us to radically solve these problems.”17 The episode was titled “Peter Thiel and the Antichrist,” and Thiel has since given closed-door lectures on the Antichrist.18

These people are not only after white-collar jobs. They promise robots that will fix your plumbing and crawl under your house. In a world that treats people as replaceable, the disabled, the weak and the loud are the first to be called expendable. That is the dark side of Silicon Valley’s transhumanism. Believe them when they tell you empathy is a weakness. And notice who is building shelters to ride out the world they are making.

Own the Town Square

Demonstrations and nonviolence alone are not enough. We need to own the town square. When I was a boy, I lived in Berkeley with my beloved parents, and I was often on the UC Berkeley campus. Walking from Bancroft Way and Telegraph Avenue past the student union toward Sproul Hall, you saw free speech happening, on the same plaza where the Free Speech Movement began in 1964.19 Students and outsiders turned old plastic milk crates upside down and stood on them to speak. They handed out flyers, answered questions and argued with people who disagreed. That was a valuable lesson, and it came long before the internet, let alone social media.

What Go Amour Teaches About the Street

My new book, Go Amour, coming soon, lays out ten principles. Five of them speak directly to anyone who takes to the streets.20

  • Make the first move (Principle 1). As the book puts it, the Golden Rule “is a rule of action. It is not a rule for standing on the side and watching.” Offering a flower to a soldier is the Golden Rule in its most active form.
  • Love is a skill (Principle 4). Erich Fromm taught that love has four parts: knowledge, respect, care and responsibility. Know who is in front of you. Respect him as a person. Care enough to stay nonviolent. Take responsibility for your street, including cleaning it the next day.
  • Human and digital rights, for ourselves and for others (Principle 5). The right to assemble is yours. So is your privacy: protect your phone and your data at a demonstration, and protect the rights of the people beside you, even the ones you disagree with.
  • A cure, or judgment (Principle 7). Loving your enemy does not mean letting him off the hook. The principle demands a cure for hate and violence from those who cause it, and if they will not change, judgment in this world, not just the next. The Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo in Argentina showed the way: “The mothers never used violence. They used their feet, their scarves and their voices. They demanded the truth first. Then they demanded judgment, in this world.”
  • We are one (Principle 8). As I wrote in No Ethics in Big Tech, the real struggle of our time is between two ideas: “I am one. And we are one.” The soldier at the barricade is one of us. The army is our brother.

This Holiday Season

Here is the lesson I hope you carry into this holiday season. Start in your community: with your friends, in your schools, at the Christmas dinner table, or wherever you gather for whatever holiday you celebrate. Practice radical love, especially toward the neglected sons and daughters in your community who lack empathy. Disarm them with love, then educate them with passion and logical arguments. Show them there is a future built on empathy, not on the apathy of Elon Musk’s and Peter Thiel’s world. Share that on social media instead of violence.

The more violence we show, the more it will be used against us to justify more military, more police and more surveillance. We cannot let the bastards win.

Live in peace, not just rest in peace.

— Vahid Razavi

Editorial assistance: Claude (Anthropic).

References

  1. “Useless eaters” (German: unnütze Esser) was Nazi-era propaganda language for people deemed unproductive. Wikipedia, “Life unworthy of life”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_unworthy_of_life
  2. Elon Musk on The Joe Rogan Experience, February 28, 2025, at about 1:16:00. Snopes fact check (via Yahoo News): https://www.yahoo.com/news/fact-check-yes-musk-said-171900322.html; NPR, March 22, 2025: https://npr.org/2025/03/22/nx-s1-5321299/how-empathy-came-to-be-seen-as-a-weakness-in-conservative-circles
  3. Vivian Jenna Wilson’s 2022 name change and decision to cut ties: https://money.yahoo.com/elon-musk-daughter-vivian-granted-160536825.html; NBC News interview, July 25, 2024: https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/elon-musk-transgender-daughter-vivian-wilson-interview-rcna163665; Snopes fact check (via Yahoo News): https://www.yahoo.com/news/fact-check-yes-musk-estranged-130000110.html
  4. Justine Wilson’s account in the documentary Musk: PinkNews, October 12, 2026: https://www.thepinknews.com/2026/10/12/elon-musk-trans-daughter-vivian-wilson-insurance/; Complex: https://www.complex.com/pop-culture/a/bernadette-giacomazzo/elon-musk-ex-wife-gaslighting
  5. Musk (2026), directed by Alex Gibney; premiered at the Venice Film Festival, released in US theaters by Bleecker Street in October 2026. Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musk_(film); Associated Press (via WDBO): https://www.wdbo.com/entertainment/alex-gibneys-musk/CRTQ34O4VA6YRPU4O45H4FNGYY/; NPR (via Michigan Public), September 10, 2026, on Musk’s lawsuit threat: https://www.michiganpublic.org/2026-09-10/elon-musk-threatens-to-sue-over-gibney-documentarys-space-lasers-claim
  6. Wikipedia, “Iranian revolution”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_revolution
  7. Martin Luther King Jr., “Loving Your Enemies,” sermon at Dexter Avenue Baptist Church, Montgomery, November 17, 1957; published in Strength to Love (1963). Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strength_to_Love
  8. Wikipedia, “Satyagraha”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satyagraha
  9. M. K. Gandhi, An Autobiography, or The Story of My Experiments with Truth: https://gandhiashramsevagram.org/autobiography/chapter-85.php
  10. Dhammapada 5, translated by Acharya Buddharakkhita: https://accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/kn/dhp/dhp.01.budd.html
  11. Wikipedia, “Flower Power (photograph)”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flower_Power_(photograph); on Allen Ginsberg coining the phrase in 1965: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flower_power
  12. Wikipedia, “Velvet Revolution”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velvet_Revolution
  13. Wikipedia, “1991 Soviet coup attempt”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1991_Soviet_coup_attempt
  14. Wikipedia, “Orange Revolution”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orange_Revolution
  15. Wikipedia, “Revolution of Dignity”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity
  16. On Grok’s sexualized images of real people and the January 14, 2026 restrictions: CNN (via WRAL): https://www.wral.com/elon-musk-s-grok-appears-to-modify-image-generation-after-outcry/22301024/; CTV News: https://www.ctvnews.ca/sci-tech/article/elon-musks-grok-can-no-longer-undress-images-of-real-people-on-x/
  17. “Peter Thiel and the Antichrist,” Interesting Times with Ross Douthat, The New York Times, June 26, 2025 (video on YouTube and nytimes.com). Transcript excerpts: TechPolicy.Press: https://techpolicy.press/digital-eugenics-and-the-extinction-of-humanity; The Nation: https://www.thenation.com/?p=561890; Comment magazine: https://comment.org/awake-o-sleeper/
  18. Salon, October 8, 2026, on Thiel’s lectures about the Antichrist: https://www.salon.com/2026/10/08/tech-leaders-embrace-trumps-super-intelligence-as-he-calls-critics-the-enemy/
  19. Wikipedia, “Free Speech Movement”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Speech_Movement
  20. Vahid Razavi, Go Amour (forthcoming), chapters 1, 4, 5, 7 and 8. The principles: https://goa.elekotech.com/principles/. No Ethics in Big Tech (2026): https://noethicsinbigtech.com/book/